In an uncommon final result, Tata Sons deferred a call on extending the time period of its chairman, N Chandrasekaran, for one more 5 years following questions from Tata Trusts chairman, Noel Tata.
Tata proved to be a robust taskmaster, elevating a number of queries about losses made by a number of unlisted firms within the $180 billion group on the board assembly and placing ahead a number of situations for approving one other time period for him.
The matter was anticipated to be a finished deal, with 4 administrators of Tata Sons in favour of extending Chandrasekaran’s tenure and able to put the difficulty to a vote. However Chandrasekaran proposed that the choice be deferred till a consensus was reached — a practice upheld by the late Ratan Tata. In brief, he needed Noel Tata’s approval for the extension.
Losses at unlisted companies
The low-profile Noel Tata, who raised questions on losses in unlisted firms, is against accumulating debt in group firms and advocates containing losses throughout these companies. Lowering losses is among the situations Noel Tata had put ahead for granting an extension. He’s evidently eager to make sure the group doesn’t develop into debt-laden, and goals to uphold the legacy of Ratan Tata.
Air India’s whole consolidated web loss was Rs. 10,859 crore in FY25, up roughly 48 per cent year-on-year in contrast with the earlier fiscal. This displays the mixed outcomes for Air India, Air India Categorical, and associated subsidiaries — taken over by the Tatas in 2022.
Tata Play reported a consolidated web lack of Rs 529.43 crore in FY25, virtually 50 per cent greater than the prior 12 months, amid decrease revenues and pricing competitors within the DTH and streaming market.
Story continues under this advert
Tata Digital posted a web lack of roughly Rs 828 crore in FY25, down from a Rs 1,201 crore loss in FY24, reflecting narrowed however ongoing losses. Disclosures point out that the group’s e-commerce and digital portfolio reported losses of round Rs 4,609.9 crore in FY25, up practically 9.5 per cent year-on-year.
Retail arm BigBasket’s consolidated web loss was Rs 2,006.8 crore in FY25, representing a rise of roughly 42 per cent from the earlier 12 months’s lack of Rs 1,415 crore, in accordance with official filings and company disclosures for the 12 months ended 31 March 2025. The corporate confronted intense competitors from rivals, together with Swiggy Instamart, Blinkit, and Zepto.
Itemizing of Tata Sons
Noel Tata is known to be against itemizing Tata Sons on the inventory exchanges. Tata Sons has utilized to the RBI for deregistration as a Non-Banking Monetary Firm (NBFC), a transfer broadly seen as an try and sidestep the central financial institution’s mandate requiring “upper-layer” NBFCs to listing. The argument is that it’s not engaged in lending and may due to this fact not be sure by monetary sector laws.
Different administrators, nonetheless, have argued that it’s a regulatory matter and ought to be left to the RBI to resolve, in accordance with a Tata group supply. When an organization is listed on inventory exchanges, it should adhere to stricter disclosure norms and adjust to laws set by the market regulator SEBI, bringing it underneath better scrutiny from traders and the general public.
Story continues under this advert
The Shapoorji Pallonji (SP) group, which holds round 18 per cent of Tata Sons, has demanded that the corporate be listed. Noel Tata — who’s married to Aloo Mistry, sister of the late Cyrus Mistry, who was ousted as Chairman of Tata Sons in 2016 — can also be eager to settle the long-running dispute with the SP group.
Deferring recent investments
With most of the group’s unlisted firms making losses, Noel Tata has advocated proscribing recent funding in new enterprise ventures. Different administrators, nonetheless, have argued in favour of continued funding for long-term stability and profitability. While no knowledge is offered on the debt of unlisted firms, companies similar to Air India carry important debt on their books. Tata Capital and Tata Applied sciences have lately raised funds via IPOs, and a number of other different companies are reportedly in discussions relating to their very own listings.
The group’s general debt burden is one other concern. Noel Tata has opposed accumulating additional debt with out first containing losses, in accordance with sources. The group, which lately break up Tata Motors into separate business and passenger car entities, can also be within the strategy of buying Italian truck maker Iveco.
June assembly to be essential
The subsequent board assembly of Tata Sons, scheduled for June, is anticipated to be pivotal, as Noel Tata and different administrators, together with Chandrasekaran, might want to resolve the query of the extension. Ought to the difficulty stay unresolved by then, uncertainty over the group’s management and strategic route will persist.
Story continues under this advert
“The matter is more likely to be resolved earlier than the June assembly. Tata Sons is the driving pressure behind the Tata group — it can not stay unresolved for lengthy with out affecting the soundness of the group,” stated a Tata group insider.
